Christmas 2024: Each year, numerous parents inform their children that a jolly old man descends the chimney at night to leave presents for well-behaved children beside their beds, departing on a sleigh. Parents instill in their children the importance of being 'good' throughout the year and the value of honesty, all in hopes of receiving gifts from Santa Claus and securing a place on his list of well-behaved children.

Nevertheless, a recent study conducted by Joseph Millum at the University of St Andrews suggests that deceiving children about Santa Claus during the Christmas season may not be advisable.

Lying undermines autonomy

While children may not yet possess the ability to make independent decisions, this does not justify the need for parents to deceive them as a means of manipulation, even if the intention is to encourage better behavior, according to the researchers. When lessons are rooted in falsehoods, children may fail to learn how to make choices based on sound reasoning.

Deception breaches trust

The bond between a child and their parents is fundamentally built on trust. Deception can disrupt this trust, complicating the child's ability to connect with their parents, the researchers noted. Parents often resort to lying to shield their children from harsh realities; however, the myth of Santa Claus does not fall into this protective category.

Consequences of a lie

The ramifications of a lie can extend far into the future. While some manipulative lies may be defensible if they serve to protect a child from harm, the case of Santa Claus calls for honesty instead.

The study concluded that lying about Santa Claus does not correlate with enhancing the joy of Christmas, fostering a child's imagination, or promoting critical thinking. Children can learn valuable morals and etiquette without the need for deception regarding Santa Claus. Therefore, the rationale for lying about Santa Claus to achieve positive outcomes is fundamentally flawed.

Read Also: From Screen Time to Family Time: Key Parenting Trends of 2024